History's Lessons Forgotten (Again)

I've rewritten this post a few times. I've settled on being as dispassionate as possible and letting the content from others speak for itself (for better or much worse). I want to avoid my own rhetoric from going off the deep end. The folks that will be quoted below handle that nicely themselves.

As is apparent here, we followed the Aneesh Chopra national CTO appointment closely. The coverage and the commentary was universally highly positive on the choice. However, there were a few minor exceptions. Some felt that a true "technologist" should have been appointed and others gave the standard issue libertarian spiel about the ironies of a government employee preaching efficiency and innovation. Fine. I totally disagree on both points and there is plenty of content out there that backs me up, but, sure, points taken.

Much more troubling was the blatant (and almost proud) racism in the reaction to the appointment by a vocal minority of story commenters.

Somehow, the fact that Chopra has an Indian heritage means that he somehow is not a "real" American, is only going hire Indians, and is part of an international conspiracy of Indians to take over the business world. All this from an all-American guy who is a massive Pittsburgh Steeler fan.

Let's state the seemingly obvious upfront: Indians are just the latest in the series of many immigrant groups to the United States made scapegoats for the natural disruptive churn that is our chosen capitalistic economy. At various times, the Irish, Italians, Polish, Jews, Chinese, Japanese, Germans, Mexicans and so on have felt the wrath for attempting to fulfill the promise of the American Dream by entering our cherished melting pot. But, what makes America America is that all have persevered and become an essential part of the fabric of our nation.

It feels strange to recite such basic elements of our country's heritage and promise, but, apparently, this is a lesson that needs to be re-learned by every generation.

Consider the comments to the Chopra appointment. (And, before you get there, it should be noted that many of the commentators cross-commented on the different stories and/or seemingly posted under different user names. I don't want to give the perception that there are more of these folks than there actually are)...

From a ZDNet story:

"Let's get off the "politically correct" bandwagon already -- there are plenty of good 'ole American boys (& girls), who are law-abiding and could do this job equally well as these imports. AMERICA FIRST."

Digg had insightful comments like this:

"Why hire an H1-B? Aren't any Americans available?"

ReadWriteWeb had these keepers:

"Before yu know it, we will all be forced to praise Allah! LOL"

"Can he PLEASE change his name to Apu, thank-you and come again!"

Wall Street Journal commentary includes:

"Aneesh will bring his 40 cousins to fill postions under him, they will bring their families from India to fill positions under them, who will bring the 40 people living in their apartment to fill positions under them and so on and so on. They will hire only Indians. They will be very good at making change and filling slushie cups, but you don’t have to be good to work in a government job."

"The invasion of the upper-caste Indians continues, and all Americans will soon be drinking out of clay cups."

"Can’t Obama find a suitable non-desi American. This is like a slap in the face for unemployed Information Technology and Engineering Americans. First their jobs were taken by Guest Workers and then outsourced to India. Now even the newly elected President does not believe in American engineers and programmers."

And, Tim O'Reilly' great post is followed by comments that include:

Tim O'Reilly: I hope someday your job is outsourced to India. Now this CTO will send all the jobs to India so what is good about that? You collaborator.

Articles like this make me want to vomit. What, everybody in I.T. has to be Hindu or of Indian decent? Americans invented the software industry, but suddenly we're an inferior race that needs to be purged out of I.T.?

That last comment came courtesy of "Kevin Flanagan" with a helpful link back to "his" blog. Here is an except of recent content there:

While the insurgency only advocates rhetorical violence and psychological cyber-warfare, here is some good news, out of all bad comes good -- four more Americans may get jobs in the I.T. industry. And there are four slots open to get a MS in I.T. from EIU...

"Four Indian students killed as drunk US cop crashes car..."

Sometimes innocents get hurt. But the alternatives are worse. So, for those of you Desis and collaborators pissed off at my cold, reckless, and tasteless disregard for the death of four Indian college students, I have one thing to say.

Shit happens.

It is called "collateral damage" in combat.

Like, what can be more tasteless than making an American I.T. professional train his semi-literate replacement? Killing a Dalit, perhaps? It happens every day. Often. And Hindus think of Americans like Dalits. They want us drinking out of Clay Cups. And if we bring up caste, they say it is none of our business. Fuck them.

I can't add anything to that.

And, P.S., I will delete any un-constructive comments.

Comments

[Sarah]

so being White is being American? Well, these people have a nasty shock coming to them. "They're" going to be in the minority pretty soon. Aneesh Chopra is as "American" as Apple Pie.

[jeff auker]

nicely written, sean. i think i too often write off the stupid-ass comment threads dangling below the articles i read online. perhaps i shouldn't. perhaps i should help take up the cause, too. thanks, man.

[David Donahue]

I don't think you can take seriously the half thought out comments of trolls or the disgruntled.

A lot of folks are unemployed right now and are lashing out at anyone and anything that contributed to their misfortune. A lot of these folks are just ranting, wallowing in their anonymity.

It's been my experience these very same folks are probably a lot more tolerant in person.

That said, I'm not so ignorant to think that there isn't inherent racism in these comments. There are a lot of ignorant and hateful folks out there and it seems sometimes like they all bought Internet access just to torment us.

For myself, I think Mr. Chopra sounds like a great choice. He has the political and government bureaucracy manipulation skills to get the job done, that a more tech focused Larry Ellison, Bill Gates or Larry Lessig (my personal choice) might not have.

[memory foam mattress]

Thanks for your information. I read your article and I like your drawing about someone eat human...hmm, I think likes alien..lol
classified |ads|memory foam mattress

[buy viagra]

He has the political and government bureaucracy manipulation skills to get the job done, that a more tech focused Larry Ellison, Bill Gates or Larry Lessig (my personal choice) might not have.

[banquet halls]

How can i find the records of me doing it and delete them or what else can i do? I delete the history on the internet but its like saved to the cpu.
banquet halls

[toronoto swingers]

Thanks for your good article. Make me know something new about historical. Thanks:)

[Link building service]

You might want to find out why and take focused action to improve it, as you’re leaving money on the table. Confirm that first before going further in the race.

[unlocked cell phone]

The English, like all Europeans, used their technology and trade items (not to mention opium and alcohol) to create an aura of superiority. If that didn't work, they used the strength of their military to intimidate and sometimes battle the Africans into submission.

[i9 phone]

Four Indian students killed as drunk US cop crashes car...

[exercise bikes]

Make more scenarios because this will be really interesting, lol.. I believe the audience will love it too. exercise bikes

[Matchmaking Service]

That's why I don't think raising taxes on anyone is good for a recession. Hoover did it and it put us in a depression. Carter did it and it led to a 10% unemployment rate.

[Speed Dating New York]

Also now with a sovereign Nation in Israel we forget what it was like to have no home, and have a very exclusive immigration policy.

[discount bathroom vanities]

You have nice story and nice picture. I will bookmark this site. Thank you

[e66 white]

A lot of folks are unemployed right now and are lashing out at anyone and anything that contributed to their misfortune. A lot of these folks are just ranting, wallowing in their anonymity.

[r4 sdhc]

Where should I buy SDHC card? I have find an game card site called http://www.r4fords.co.uk/ in where owns the best cards,such as [url="http://www.r4fords.co.uk/"] acekard 2i[/url],[url="http://www.r4fords.co.uk/"] r4 sdhc
[/url], [url="http://www.r4fords.co.uk/"] r4 revolution sdhc[/url]，[url="http://www.r4fords.co.uk/"] r4 upgrade revolution sdhc[/url]，[url="http://www.r4fords.co.uk/"] r4 ultra sdhc[/url]and so on . but I'm not sure reliable? Who can improving some suggestions? Thanks....

[ray ban sunglasses]

http://www.eightshop.com polo shirts
Your idea coincides with mine.and I think it's better.

[Jordan 1]

Each of the simple life is desired! Sometimes people can not simply live! Often feel tired! Really frustrating! So people should maintain a childlike innocence

[Promotional Items]

As long as fear can be used as a weapon and the truth can be denied by those who perpetrate these horrible crimes, the world will never be a better place. You're very correct.
Promotional Items

[online college course]

Great author! It was a good content and very informative post. Also It has a lot of great points. I do hope to see another great article from you.

[Web hosting]

This is really awesome, just keep updating us on the latest, really love what you have been doing, keep up the great work.

[build lean muscle]

I personally like this blog and appreciates your efforts. Thanks for sharing this. Great job!

[logo design]

Working on the give topic is really a difficult task but your this tutorial made it easy for me to handle it without any problem. If anyone seeking information then this blog is the best place for him as it has quality content for your required information. Thanks for sharing.

[manchester computer repairs]

I certainly enjoyed the way you explore your experience and knowledge of the subject! Keep up on it. Thanks for sharing the info

[link building services]

Very good information about Flash Games Programmer, thank you very much by the article and the quality of your Web site.