3Qs with Adam Thierer on the MySpace/AG Child Safety Effort

PFF Senior Fellow Adam Thierer wrote the book on online child protection, so who better to give insight on today's long-awaited MySpace/Attorney General agreement to create protections for kids using the News Corp site.

And, no really, Adam did write the book. (You can download "Parental Controls and Online Child Protection: A Survey of Tools and Methods" here.)

Before we get to the Q&A, here is a brief overview/opinion of the agreement courtesy of NYT's Brad Stone:

Among the dozens of measures MySpace has agreed to take, the social network will let parents submit the e-mail addresses of their children, so the company can prevent anyone from using that address to set up a profile. It will also set the profiles of all 16 and 17-year-olds to private, so only their established online friends can visit their pages - essentially creating a “closed” section for users under age 18.

MySpace also promises to hire a contractor to identify and delete pornographic images on the site. And the company will take charge of an Internet safety technical task force to develop an age and identity verification tools for social networking sites.

Now, to Adam...

Q: Why is today’s AG/MySpace announcement significant? What about this tells you that this will be more substantive than the veritable “blue ribbon committee” that peaks at launch?

The agreement is significant because it represents a sensible step forward in terms of online safety. Indeed, many of the principles in the agreement could form a potential model “code of conduct” that other social networking sites could adopt. That is important because (a) it really could help keep kids safer online; and (b) it will help us avoid the specter of government regulation of the Internet and others forms of digital communication.

The agreement with the AGs is especially notable for what it does not include: age verification mandates. The call for an Internet Safety Technical Task Force to study online safety methods and identity authentication tools is a sensible alternative to the rush to mandate age verification, which some AGs have been advocating vociferously over the past two years.

Hopefully the task force will provide critical examination of the issue and not simply begin with pre-ordained conclusions about the wisdom or effectiveness of online age verification techniques and technologies. At the press conference announcing the agreement, however, Attorneys General Roy Cooper of North Carolina and Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut seemed to imply that that the goal of the task force would be to develop and implement a full-blown age verification system for the Internet. “We are going to find and develop online identity authentication tools,” said AG Cooper. And AG Blumenthal reiterated an argument he made ad nauseum last year that, “if we can put a man on the moon,” then we ought to be able to verify the ages of people before they go online.

But it’s just not that simple. As I argued in a lengthy PFF study last year entitled, “Social Networking and Age Verification: Many Hard Questions; No Easy Solutions,” there are no silver bullet age verifications solutions. Online authentication is a complicated, multi-faceted technical issue. And, even assuming we could find a way to make it work, there are many other considerations that must be taken into account, such as the burden it might impose of freedom of speech or individual privacy.

The danger, therefore, is that the AGs have a pre-ordained conclusion and that they will either stack the deck on the task force with age verification advocates or pressure the task force to adopt mandatory age verification without thoroughly studying the issue. Again, that would be a serious mistake and it would also likely give rise to legal challenges.

Q: What other companies are critical to making the Internet Safety Technical Task Force successful? And, as far as you know, was their consideration to having them involved prior to this announcement?

If the task force does go forward, it needs to be a balanced panel of experts and include other social networking players, such as Facebook. This shouldn’t just be a MySpace thing.

Q: While this obviously is targeted towards collaborations with state law enforcement, what do you think the DC impact will be of the Internet Safety Technical Task Force?

Some AGs have tried to get the federal government involved in the effort to regulate social networking sites, but so far nothing has come of that. Ironically, if anyone was going to take the lead in terms of social networking regulation, it should be the federal government—not the states—since the Internet is not a local medium or platform. In fact, that’s one of the reasons why the AGs have wisely not pursued any formal legal action against MySpace thus far; they know it would likely be struck down as an unconstitutional burden on what is clearly interstate commerce.

Of course, the last thing I want is more federal Internet meddling and silly bills like the Deleting Online Predators Act (DOPA) that are completely counter-productive. If the feds get involved at all, it should be in terms of education and awareness building about sensible online safety efforts and parental empowerment tools. They should adopt an “educate first” approach to the issue. But I have a sneaking suspicion that, to the extent they do get involved, they will once again take the “regulate first” approach.

Comments

[discount coach]

these are times with more liberty,but less joy; we have much more food,but less nutrition;who could told me why?

[volumerates]

The new online shopping concept to bring you convenient and fast service, cheap products, a variety of products, you can always find what you want, bulk purchase: more cheaper, all the best experience in the VRS.
http://www.volumerates.com/category/cyclods

[ugg sale]

efforts and parental empowerment

[Technine MFM Classic]

good good�this post deserves nothing :( �hahaha just joking :P �nice post :P

[mbt shoes]

i like your blog!

[r4i]

Too much money is not very well.I hate for my life....
http://www.newyorknds.com
http://www.tech4mods.com
http://www.mod4game.com

[仙台 マッサージ]

The blog is very good,I like it very much.
http://www.asiankou.com/

[カード現金化]

ありがとうございます

[Kamagra Oral Jelly]

Skönt att vara besöka din blogg igen, har det varit månader för mig. Väl här artikeln som jag har väntat så länge. Jag behöver den här artikeln för att slutföra mitt uppdrag i kollegiet, och den har samma tema med din artikel. Tack, bra aktie..

[Mobile Computing]

I've been searching for this topic for years. I'm glad of having finding it. It's a fantastic issue, and a beautiful photograph. Thanks for everything you have taught me!

[buy from china]

China is among the most globe's most significant producer of electronics industries, producing more Mp3's, Camcorders, Video Players, Electronic Gadgets, and also other high tech merchandise than all other nation.

[MBT]

I'm glad of having finding it.That's very good!

[スーパーコピー]

The new online shopping concept to bring you convenient and fast service
http://www.japanbrand777.com/

[モンクレール]

http://www.hotmoncler.jp/
Of course, the last thing I want is more federal Internet meddling and silly bills like the Deleting Online Predators Act (DOPA) that are completely counter-productive

[ベトプティック]

Great tips, I would like to join your blog anyway,

[timberland boots]

Don’t cry because it is over,smile because it happened.http://www.uggsauto.com/
http://www.gianmarcosandals.com/
http://www.studioredsoxeditionheadphones.com

[china wholesale]

Good post.You did a good work,and offer more effective imformation for us!Thank you.

[Cheap sale jordan]

The article is worth reading, I like it very much. I will keep your new articles.

[brand name handbags]

This article is informative and interesting,I enjoy reading it.

[モンクレール]

I've been searching for this topic for years. I'm glad of having finding it. It's a fantastic issue, and a beautiful photograph. Thanks for everything you have taught me!

[オメガ 人気]

ミヤビナオ-人気(OMEGA)オメガ 時計、オメガ 腕時計、オメガ アンティーク通販店舗
www.omega-aa.com

[Account Deleted]

Of course, the last thing I want is more federal Internet meddling and silly bills like the Deleting Online Predators Act (DOPA) that are completely counter-productivehttp://www.discountwomenshop.com/ Christian Louboutin Heels
http://www.bootsalestore.com/ Christian Louboutin Boots
http://www.cheapuggbuttonboots.com/ UGGブーツ
http://www.salelexanderwang.com/ Alexander Wang Rocco

[アバクロ 通販]

Of course, the last thing I want is more federal Internet meddling and silly bills like the Deleting Online Predators Act (DOPA) that are completely counter-productivアバクロ ダウン レディース http://www.afinjapan.com/category-528-b0.html
アバクロ ダウンジャケット http://www.afinjapan.com/category-529-b0.html
アバクロ ダウンベスト http://www.afinjapan.com/category-530-b0.html
アバクロ カップル http://www.afinjapan.com/category-521-b0.html

[トリーバーチ 靴]

トリーバーチ 靴 http://www.vikishoes.com
トリーバーチ シューズ http://www.vikishoes.com
トリーバーチ フラットシューズ http://www.vikishoes.com/5--

[Steph]

I'm looking to get permission to use the photo that accompanies this post. Would someone from 463 Communications be able to direct me to the proper person to seek this permission. Thanks!